Potter County Republican Party Asks Federal Court for Hand Count of Every Texas Ballot

The Potter County Commissioners Court on Monday authorized County Attorney Scott Brumley to defend Elections Administrator Christy Benge in a federal lawsuit that asks for every ballot cast in Texas in the midterm election held Nov. 3 to be tallied by hand, according to the Amarillo Tribune.

Brumley moved to dismiss the case the same day. The motion says the plaintiffs have no standing to sue and that the harm they describe is “speculative rather than imminent” and cannot fairly be linked to anything Benge did.

The Potter County Republican Party and its chairman, Daniel Rogers, filed the suit Oct. 27 in the federal court in Amarillo, and it was assigned to Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk. Benge is named in her official capacity, and the plaintiffs want her treated as a stand-in for election administrators in all 254 Texas counties. They want the judge to require a manual tally of paper ballots, checked against machine results, ahead of the canvass.

The complaint cites the risk that AI software or other “malicious actors” could interfere, and says voting equipment contains components made in countries hostile to the U.S., China among them. The suit makes no allegation of misconduct by Benge, and it does not claim that any earlier election result in Potter County or elsewhere in Texas was altered or miscounted.

Texas law already requires election offices to hand count a portion of ballots as an audit. The plaintiffs call that check too limited to protect against the threat they describe.

Several groups have asked to join the case as defendants, including the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, the NAACP Texas State Conference and the League of Women Voters of Texas. A filing by the two Democratic committees, submitted before Election Day, says counting millions of ballots by hand accurately within the state’s post-election timelines “is not possible.” Preliminary returns show 9.9 million or more Texans voted in the election.

Potter County commissioners are set to certify the county’s results Friday morning, and the statewide deadline is Tuesday, Nov. 17. The plaintiffs’ lawyers have asked the court for until Thursday on their request for a preliminary injunction. As of the Tribune’s report, Kacsmaryk had not ruled on that request.

No Comments

Post A Comment