Federal lawsuit challenges prayer at Rio Hondo ISD staff meetings

A former Rio Hondo Middle School teacher has taken the Rio Hondo Independent School District to federal court, alleging that prayers led by district leaders at required staff meetings infringed on his constitutional rights, according to The Brownsville Herald.

Juan Antonio Castillo, who taught Spanish at the school between August 2023 and last June, filed the complaint Oct. 28 in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas in Brownsville. Named as defendants are the district, Superintendent Raul Javier Trevino and school board President Eddie Guerra. Castillo has worked in Valley public schools for more than 25 years and identifies as a Humanist, which the complaint describes as a belief system without a deity that relies on reason and compassion.

The lawsuit says Castillo had to attend districtwide staff meetings every August, December and May, and that Trevino or Guerra opened them with Christian prayer. According to the complaint, Castillo voiced concerns and the district did not act, leaving him to choose between going against his beliefs and risking ostracism or professional consequences. The American Humanist Association, which is supporting the case, said in a news release that employees were not warned beforehand that prayer would be part of the meetings, were told to stand and bow their heads, and were given no chance to opt out.

Castillo alleges violations of the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause, Free Exercise Clause and Free Speech Clause. He asks the court to declare that the defendants broke the law, to permanently bar the practice and to award damages, either compensatory or nominal, along with legal fees and expenses.

Trevino told the Herald on Friday that the district had yet to be formally served but was aware of the suit and was reviewing it with its legal department, adding that it was too early to comment. On Monday, he said the district had nothing more to add.

No Comments

Post A Comment