
17 Nov Weslaco Asks Texas Attorney General to Rule on Releasing Parts of Firefighter Deaths Report
Weslaco has requested an opinion from the Texas Attorney General’s Office on whether parts of the police file on the deaths of two city firefighters can be kept from the public, according to The Monitor.
The question arose after someone filed a public information request for the report. City legal counsel Ben Castillo laid out the city’s position in a letter to the attorney general’s office. He described a 15-page file made up of narrative supplements written from Nov. 2 to Nov. 13, covering the physical evidence, a review of phones and other digital records, interviews and the investigators’ findings. Nobody faced arrest or charges, he wrote.
The city is relying on common-law privacy to protect two categories of material. The first involves statements from two witnesses about a woman’s previous relationship with Lt. Juan Peña Jr., plus details of his divorce and custody arrangements for his minor children. Castillo wrote that the woman holds no public office and that investigators did not name her a suspect or place her at the scene of what happened Oct. 27 and 28. Since she could be recognized from the surrounding context, the city is asking to hold back the passages entirely. In his view, the public has “no legitimate interest” in the material, because it has nothing to do with the city’s or the police department’s response.
The second category covers descriptions of the bodies of Peña and of Julia Divine Rocha, 21, including their condition and the circumstances of their discovery and removal from the residence. Castillo said the city is informing both families of the request so they can weigh in with the attorney general’s office, and that they may raise privacy concerns about those sections or any others.
Weslaco police have ruled the deaths accidental, caused by carbon monoxide, and closed the case. A department spokesperson said the findings are with the forensic examiner’s office for a final report.
Additional timeline details came Oct. 30 from Justice of the Peace Gilberto Saenz, Precinct 1, Place 1, who said the pair reached Knapp Medical Center, arriving 7:46 a.m. Oct. 28. Peña was declared dead around 8:30 a.m. and Rocha around 8:47 a.m. Police have not said where the exposure took place or what the source was.
No Comments